Findings
The findings of the pilot study show where people with disabilities encounter barriers in everyday life. The following overview summarises the most frequent themes, separately for each testing method. The charts use neutral labels for the websites. The original findings remain in Inclusion Monitor.
Cross-cutting findings
Recurring barriers since 2016
Some obstacles already highlighted by the 2016 study persist:
- PDF: 91 of 93 distinct automatically tested PDFs have at least one rule violation. Manual testing comprises 25 assessments of 20 documents; 4 documents meet the Quick Test’s “conforming” threshold (6 points or more).
- Forms: Missing or unclear labels and hard-to-recognise error messages make independent completion difficult.
- Screen reader structure: Headings, regions and names are missing or incorrectly marked up.
New areas of attention
- Easy-to-read language: Only 6 of 101 checked websites provide a recognisable entry point to easy-to-read content on the home page. In the detailed assessment of 33 websites, such content is prominently findable on only 2. Where present, texts are usually understandable, but difficult to find and rarely marked with the icon.
- New WCAG 2.2 requirements: The new requirements are included in testing. Keyboard focus obscured by banners or fixed headers (2.4.11) is among the observed deficiencies.
- Accessibility statements: 23 of 28 manually tested websites are recorded as non-conformant in the accessibility-statement test; 5 as conformant. The supplementary automated check recognised a statement on 8 of 101 websites.
Results from embedded content
For the three rules below, false positives about the whole page arise when the software applies them to embedded content such as advertising, cookie dialogs or social-media elements. For the 94 selected axe runs, the table shows how many websites are affected and how many have an affected node in the main document.
| Test rule (mapped criterion) | With a report | Of these, in the main document | Only in embedded content |
|---|---|---|---|
Page language — html-has-lang (3.1.1) |
52 | 7 | 45 |
Page title — document-title (2.4.2) |
47 | 3 | 44 |
Zooming — meta-viewport (1.4.4) |
15 | 10 | 5 |
Among the 22 manually tested websites with an axe result, counts fall from 16 to 1 for html-has-lang, from 15 to 2 for document-title, and from 5 to 2 for meta-viewport when only the main document is considered. In total, 25 manual Web runs are selected; 3 of those websites have no selected axe result.
These are rule-level counts, not recalculated criterion values: other rules may contribute to the same criterion. Across all rules, 285 of 962 violation findings concern embedded content only; they are not all false positives. Bars and rankings retain the recorded results. A correction to the integration for the named page-level rules is planned for future runs.
Manual and automated: comparing the same selected group
For each criterion, manual and automated results appear directly side by side, or immediately one below the other on narrow screens. Both sides use the websites whose completed manual web test runs are selected for domain compliance. Websites without recorded automated results remain in the selection and are shown as missing. Each website counts once per mapped criterion and method. Weights for the reliability of automated results can be derived from accumulated data by comparing manual and automated test runs.
Manual eCH Web assessment · 2.1.0 / Automated WCAG checks (axe) · 1.2.0
Manually selected websites: 25 · Completed evidence
Automated WCAG checks (axe) — With recorded results for this method: 21 · Without recorded results for this method: 4
Common scale for both bars: 0–25 websites.
Testing scope of websites with both methods: Different assessed scopes: 3; Same recorded scope: 18
Automated WCAG checks (axe) — Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21. Applies to automated rows marked * and all websites with automated evidence included in those rows.
1.3.1 — Info and Relationships
Manual eCH Web assessment: 25 / 25Result states (25)
- Recorded violation: 25
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 4 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Additional notes (may overlap): Evidence or mapping not assured: 21Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Review required: 1
- Unassessed or unavailable: 16
- Recorded violation: 4
4.1.2 — Name, Role, Value
Manual eCH Web assessment: 25 / 25Result states (25)
- Recorded violation: 25
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 19 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Incomplete results: 1
- Review required: 1
- Recorded violation: 19
1.1.1 — Non-text Content
Manual eCH Web assessment: 24 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 1
- Recorded violation: 24
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 13 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Incomplete results: 8
- Recorded violation: 13
2.4.2 — Page Titled
Manual eCH Web assessment: 18 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 7
- Recorded violation: 18
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 15 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Incomplete results: 6
- Recorded violation: 15
2.4.4 — Link Purpose (In Context)
Manual eCH Web assessment: 18 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 7
- Recorded violation: 18
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 12 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Incomplete results: 9
- Recorded violation: 12
2.4.6 — Headings and Labels
Manual eCH Web assessment: 21 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 4
- Recorded violation: 21
Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- No mapped rule: 21
2.4.3 — Focus Order
Manual eCH Web assessment: 20 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 5
- Recorded violation: 20
Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- No mapped rule: 21
1.4.3 — Contrast (Minimum)
Manual eCH Web assessment: 19 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 6
- Recorded violation: 19
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 14 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Review required: 7
- Recorded violation: 14
2.1.1 — Keyboard
Manual eCH Web assessment: 16 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 9
- Recorded violation: 16
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 2 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Incomplete results: 19
- Recorded violation: 2
2.4.11 — Focus Not Obscured (Minimum)
Manual eCH Web assessment: 16 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 9
- Recorded violation: 16
Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- No mapped rule: 21
3.1.1 — Language of Page
Manual eCH Web assessment: 2 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 23
- Recorded violation: 2
Automated WCAG checks (axe): 16 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Incomplete results: 5
- Recorded violation: 16
3.3.2 — Labels or Instructions
Manual eCH Web assessment: 16 / 25Result states (25)
- Not applicable: 1
- Assessed without a violation: 8
- Recorded violation: 16
Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4Completeness note *Result states (25)
- No recorded results for this method: 4
- Incomplete results: 20
- Review required: 1
All corresponding criteria compared
| Criterion | Manual eCH Web assessment | Automated WCAG checks (axe) | Websites with criterion evidence / selection |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3.1 — Info and Relationships | Manual eCH Web assessment: 25 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 4 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21; Evidence or mapping not assured: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 4.1.2 — Name, Role, Value | Manual eCH Web assessment: 25 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 19 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.1.1 — Non-text Content | Manual eCH Web assessment: 24 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 13 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.2 — Page Titled | Manual eCH Web assessment: 18 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 15 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.4 — Link Purpose (In Context) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 18 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 12 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.6 — Headings and Labels | Manual eCH Web assessment: 21 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.3 — Focus Order | Manual eCH Web assessment: 20 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.3 — Contrast (Minimum) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 19 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 14 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.1.1 — Keyboard | Manual eCH Web assessment: 16 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 2 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.11 — Focus Not Obscured (Minimum) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 16 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.1.1 — Language of Page | Manual eCH Web assessment: 2 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 16 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.2 — Labels or Instructions | Manual eCH Web assessment: 16 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.4 — Resize text | Manual eCH Web assessment: 11 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 5 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.7 — Focus Visible | Manual eCH Web assessment: 15 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.1 — Error Identification | Manual eCH Web assessment: 15 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.1 — Bypass Blocks | Manual eCH Web assessment: 14 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.2.2 — Pause, Stop, Hide | Manual eCH Web assessment: 13 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.3 — Label in Name | Manual eCH Web assessment: 13 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.5 — Identify Input Purpose | Manual eCH Web assessment: 12 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.3 — Error Suggestion | Manual eCH Web assessment: 11 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 4.1.3 — Status Messages | Manual eCH Web assessment: 10 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.11 — Non-Text Contrast | Manual eCH Web assessment: 9 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.10 — Reflow | Manual eCH Web assessment: 8 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.12 — Text Spacing | Manual eCH Web assessment: 8 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.3 — Audio Description or Media Alternative (Prerecorded) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 6 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.5 — Audio Description (Prerecorded) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 6 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.2 — Captions (Prerecorded) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 5 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.2 — Meaningful Sequence | Manual eCH Web assessment: 4 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.1 — Use of Color | Manual eCH Web assessment: 4 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): 2 / 25No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.5 — Images of Text | Manual eCH Web assessment: 2 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.1 — Audio-only and Video-only (Prerecorded) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.1.2 — No Keyboard Trap | Manual eCH Web assessment: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.5 — Multiple Ways | Manual eCH Web assessment: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.2 — Pointer Cancellation | Manual eCH Web assessment: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.1 — On Focus | Manual eCH Web assessment: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.6 — Consistent Help | Manual eCH Web assessment: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.4 — Captions (Live) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.3 — Sensory Characteristics | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.4 — Orientation | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.13 — Content on Hover or Focus | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.2 — Audio Control | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.1.4 — Character Key Shortcuts | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.2.1 — Timing Adjustable | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.3.1 — Three Flashes or Below Threshold | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.1 — Pointer Gestures | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.4 — Motion Actuation | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.7 — Dragging Movements | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.8 — Target Size (Minimum) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.1.2 — Language of Parts | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): Not availableNo recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Completeness not confirmed: 21
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.2 — On Input | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.3 — Consistent Navigation | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.4 — Consistent Identification | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.4 — Error Prevention (Legal, Financial, Data) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.7 — Redundant Entry | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.8 — Accessible Authentication (Minimum) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
| 4.1.1 — Parsing (obsolete) | Manual eCH Web assessment: 0 / 25 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Evidence or mapping not assured: 7
| Automated WCAG checks (axe): No mapped rule: 21No recorded results for this method: 4 Result states (25)
| 25 / 25 |
Data basis and sources
manual-automated-v4 · 7d4e21a1256b2375f0c336a43c2c090424b67a2350ffc7bfd6b383d5b1e01255
checklist-ech-0059-web · 2.1.0 ·
wcag22-automated-axe · 1.2.0 ·
checklist-ech-0059-web · 2.0.0 ·
adis-web-wcag-aa-manual · 2026-11-07.1 · afbaceb79c5525117679fe7e510557d1e95ae200e375d770539e16594120d115
adis-web-wcag-aa-automated · 2026-11-07.1 · 99167cf7de6eb9ecc95f8757c0c610a88ce3f5195eb5fcb93dd5d3d778cd09d9
eCH-0059: ech-0059
WCAG 2.2: wcag2.2
method-version-excluded: 1
Interpreting the manual findings
It is striking how often basic requirements are not met:
- Structure: Headings, lists and tables are often recognisable visually but not technically. Screen readers cannot convey them in that case.
- Controls: Buttons, menus and form fields have no accessible name or the wrong one. Screen reader and voice control users cannot tell what a control does.
- Alternative text: It is missing or does not describe the content.
- Keyboard use: People working without a mouse often lose their bearings because the focus is invisible, obscured or moves in an illogical order.
Interpreting the automated findings
Automated findings include the name, role and value of controls, such as accessible button names. Other examples concern contrast, link text, language declarations and page titles. The ranking states which websites have automated results and where these are missing. Missing results do not mean a passed test. Comparing the two methods shows that a good automated result alone does not make a website accessible.
Where manual deficiencies have no automated deficiency signal
The left side shows websites with a manual deficiency; the right shows the subset without an automated deficiency signal for the same criterion. Both use the same manually selected group. The breakdown distinguishes missing results, missing testing rules and other automated states.
Manual eCH Web assessment · 2.1.0 / Automated WCAG checks (axe) · 1.2.0
Manually selected websites: 25 · Completed evidence
Automated WCAG checks (axe) — With recorded results for this method: 21 · Without recorded results for this method: 4
Common scale for both bars: 0–25 websites.
Testing scope of websites with both methods: Different assessed scopes: 3; Same recorded scope: 18
1.3.1 — Info and Relationships
Websites with a manual deficiency: 25 / 25Result states (25)
- Recorded violation: 25
Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 21 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 4. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Review required: 1; Unassessed or unavailable: 162.4.6 — Headings and Labels
Websites with a manual deficiency: 21 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 4
- Recorded violation: 21
Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 21 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; No mapped rule: 172.4.3 — Focus Order
Websites with a manual deficiency: 20 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 5
- Recorded violation: 20
Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 20 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; No mapped rule: 162.4.11 — Focus Not Obscured (Minimum)
Websites with a manual deficiency: 16 / 25Result states (25)
- Assessed without a violation: 9
- Recorded violation: 16
Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 16 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 3; No mapped rule: 133.3.2 — Labels or Instructions
Websites with a manual deficiency: 16 / 25Result states (25)
- Not applicable: 1
- Assessed without a violation: 8
- Recorded violation: 16
Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 16 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Incomplete results: 11; Review required: 1
All criteria: manual violations and automated signals
| Criterion | Websites with a manual deficiency | Of these, without an automated deficiency signal | Websites with criterion evidence / selection |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3.1 — Info and Relationships | Websites with a manual deficiency: 25 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 21 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 4. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Review required: 1; Unassessed or unavailable: 16 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.6 — Headings and Labels | Websites with a manual deficiency: 21 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 21 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; No mapped rule: 17 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.3 — Focus Order | Websites with a manual deficiency: 20 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 20 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; No mapped rule: 16 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.11 — Focus Not Obscured (Minimum) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 16 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 16 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 3; No mapped rule: 13 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.2 — Labels or Instructions | Websites with a manual deficiency: 16 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 16 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Incomplete results: 11; Review required: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.7 — Focus Visible | Websites with a manual deficiency: 15 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 15 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 2; No mapped rule: 13 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.1 — Error Identification | Websites with a manual deficiency: 15 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 15 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 1; No mapped rule: 14 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.1.1 — Keyboard | Websites with a manual deficiency: 16 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 14 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 2. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Incomplete results: 10 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.1 — Bypass Blocks | Websites with a manual deficiency: 14 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 14 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 1; Incomplete results: 12; Review required: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.2.2 — Pause, Stop, Hide | Websites with a manual deficiency: 13 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 13 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 3; Incomplete results: 10 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.3 — Label in Name | Websites with a manual deficiency: 13 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 13 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; No mapped rule: 9 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.5 — Identify Input Purpose | Websites with a manual deficiency: 12 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 12 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 12 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.1.1 — Non-text Content | Websites with a manual deficiency: 24 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 11 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 13. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Incomplete results: 7 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.3 — Error Suggestion | Websites with a manual deficiency: 11 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 11 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 11 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.4 — Resize text | Websites with a manual deficiency: 11 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 10 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 1. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 3; Incomplete results: 7 | 25 / 25 |
| 4.1.3 — Status Messages | Websites with a manual deficiency: 10 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 10 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 10 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.4 — Link Purpose (In Context) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 18 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 9 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 9. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 3; Incomplete results: 6 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.11 — Non-Text Contrast | Websites with a manual deficiency: 9 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 9 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 9 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.10 — Reflow | Websites with a manual deficiency: 8 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 8 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 1; No mapped rule: 7 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.12 — Text Spacing | Websites with a manual deficiency: 8 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 8 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 8 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.2 — Page Titled | Websites with a manual deficiency: 18 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 7 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 11. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Incomplete results: 3 | 25 / 25 |
| 4.1.2 — Name, Role, Value | Websites with a manual deficiency: 25 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 6 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 19. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Incomplete results: 1; Review required: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.3 — Audio Description or Media Alternative (Prerecorded) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 6 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 6 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 1; No mapped rule: 5 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.5 — Audio Description (Prerecorded) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 6 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 6 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 1; No mapped rule: 5 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.3 — Contrast (Minimum) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 19 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 5 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 14. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 4; Review required: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.2 — Captions (Prerecorded) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 5 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 5 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 1; Incomplete results: 2; Review required: 2 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.2 — Meaningful Sequence | Websites with a manual deficiency: 4 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 4 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 4 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.1 — Use of Color | Websites with a manual deficiency: 4 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 2 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 2. States of the remaining websites: Incomplete results: 2 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.5 — Images of Text | Websites with a manual deficiency: 2 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 2 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 2 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.1 — Audio-only and Video-only (Prerecorded) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 1 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: Incomplete results: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.1.2 — No Keyboard Trap | Websites with a manual deficiency: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 1 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.4.5 — Multiple Ways | Websites with a manual deficiency: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 1 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.2 — Pointer Cancellation | Websites with a manual deficiency: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 1 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No recorded results for this method: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.1 — On Focus | Websites with a manual deficiency: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 1 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.6 — Consistent Help | Websites with a manual deficiency: 1 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 1 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0. States of the remaining websites: No mapped rule: 1 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.1.1 — Language of Page | Websites with a manual deficiency: 2 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 2 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.2.4 — Captions (Live) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.3 — Sensory Characteristics | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.3.4 — Orientation | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.13 — Content on Hover or Focus | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 1.4.2 — Audio Control | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.1.4 — Character Key Shortcuts | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.2.1 — Timing Adjustable | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.3.1 — Three Flashes or Below Threshold | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.1 — Pointer Gestures | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.4 — Motion Actuation | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.7 — Dragging Movements | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 2.5.8 — Target Size (Minimum) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.1.2 — Language of Parts | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.2 — On Input | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.3 — Consistent Navigation | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.2.4 — Consistent Identification | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.4 — Error Prevention (Legal, Financial, Data) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.7 — Redundant Entry | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 3.3.8 — Accessible Authentication (Minimum) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25)
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
| 4.1.1 — Parsing (obsolete) | Websites with a manual deficiency: 0 / 25 Result states (25) Additional notes (may overlap): Evidence or mapping not assured: 7
| Of these, without an automated deficiency signal: 0 / 25With an automated deficiency signal for the same website and criterion: 0 | 25 / 25 |
Data basis and sources
manual-automated-v4 · 7d4e21a1256b2375f0c336a43c2c090424b67a2350ffc7bfd6b383d5b1e01255
checklist-ech-0059-web · 2.1.0 ·
wcag22-automated-axe · 1.2.0 ·
checklist-ech-0059-web · 2.0.0 ·
adis-web-wcag-aa-manual · 2026-11-07.1 · afbaceb79c5525117679fe7e510557d1e95ae200e375d770539e16594120d115
adis-web-wcag-aa-automated · 2026-11-07.1 · 99167cf7de6eb9ecc95f8757c0c610a88ce3f5195eb5fcb93dd5d3d778cd09d9
eCH-0059: ech-0059
WCAG 2.2: wcag2.2
method-version-excluded: 1
